Monday, October 5, 2020

TURNOUT TELL-ALL

The end of the pandemic is in sight. ~ Donald Trump (9/29/20)     

Here we are a mere 28 days before we choose whether the incumbent, possibly covid-filled president should remain in office or cast him out in favor of his eminently-laudable challenger.

But wait, a top-of-the ninth (or is it just the seventh inning stretch) colossal curve ball has been thrown into this political game, worthy of Sandy Koufax or Dwight Gooden. The curve ball is the Friday, October 2 announcement that #45 has covid-19. It’s highjacked the election, probably just as the president hoped. To no one’s surprise, his administration has itself become a super-spreader event.

Yup, viral reality has likely stricken our here-to-fore, ever-unmasked #45. I say likely because we should balance three concurrent realities. First, this virus’ months-long, utterly non-discriminatory and all-too-successful efforts to infect everyone; second, #45’s regular no-rules denials of fact, science and truth (see his quote above, QED); and third, #45’s on-going and widening deficit in election polls. Given this state of affairs, my amply well-founded, cynical self has pondered that he could be making up his infection for his own desperate advantage on November 3.

On Sunday, the seemingly non-stricken #45 briefly left his suite at Walter Reed National Military Medical Center for a short, unannounced motorcade ride so he could wave to his supporters outside. The president’s un-sick behavior was properly labeled by doctors at Walter Reed as irresponsible “insanity.” It’s only insanity if he actually has covid-19. Imagine him triumphantly returning to the White House all too soon, saying he’s facilely “fired the virus.”  

Because of his nefarious approach to politics, I urge the Dems to walk a fine line and not to be too considerate about the president’s viral condition. If they are too thoughtful, as is their virtuous inclination, they could become hoodwinked toast. Remember not the Maine, but hopeful victory on the 3rd, please.

The Repubs haven’t stopped a single one of their negative ads against Mr. Biden, as the president waved to his fans in his SUV outside Walter Reed. The Dems have ceased theirs against #45. This befits a risky tactic of perhaps being overly empathetic of the president’s (alleged) medical malady. Joe, please restart your full court press and all your ads, now.

But back to the upcoming balloting for the presidency.

In this seemingly-interminable presidential election cycle, analysts have guesstimated that the number of “undecideds” may range from 3% to 11% of registered voters; most polls show 3% to 5% at most. For the life of me, I don’t know how our presidential choice this time can be at all puzzling; which is another way of saying that the media’s obsessive focus on allegedly “undecided” voters is a misplaced ruse. At this point, there aren’t any really “undecided” voters to speak of. But the giant media election apparatus really, really requires them for their stories as well as the debates. Remember the debates?  

The incentive for someone to say now they’re “undecided” rests solely on receiving a slender, Skinnerian pellet of spotlighted, momentary media attention. “You’re really undecided; that’s fabulous, can we please interview you?” The media’s spotlight is probably bright enough for a few people to apparently want to bath in it. To assist those very, very few remaining "undecided" voters, I suggest you take this handy quiz to learn what you should do on election day. 

Other analysts believe most of these very scarce “undecided” voters aren’t likely voters. Past information indicates all too many will not vote on November 3. From this perspective, there are mainly “undecided” non-voters.

Despite the intensity and importance of every US presidential election, vast swaths of eligible voters regularly decline their privilege. The US Elections Project has determined that 39.9% of our voting-eligible population, or 45.3% of our voting-age population, did not vote in November 2016. Our paltry election turnout-participation rate ranked the US 26th highest of the 35 listed, advanced democracies, just behind Estonia.[1] The hefty number of non-voting citizens is in part why election campaigns focus on improving turnout and “getting the vote out.”

The table below shows the voter turnout and related information for the 2018 primary and Congressional elections and the 2016 presidential election for several major voting groups. Voter turnout is the percentage of eligible voters who cast a ballot in an election. In 2016, the national average turnout of voting-age people was 59%. Minnesota had the highest voter turnout of any state in 2016 and 2018.

Voter Turnout and Electorate Shares by Ethnicity and Age

Group

Voter Turnout

2018      2016

Share of Electorate

2018      2016

Share of 2019 Pop.

Non-Hispanic White

55.2%    64.7%

73.3%    73.6%

60.1%

Hispanic

36.9       44.9

  9.4          9.1

18.5

Non-Hispanic Black

51.3       59.9

12.2        12.3

13.4

18-29 years old

32.6       43.4

13.8        15.7

16.4

60+ years old

65.5      71.4

37.3        33.6

16.5 (65+)

Sources: US Elections Project, US Census, Marketingcharts.com

As shown in the table, non-Hispanic White people and people 60 years old or over, aka elder voters, had the highest turnout, closely followed by non-Hispanic Black people, a key Dem constituency. Younger people, a hopeful Dem constituency, had the lowest turnout, half that of elder voters in 2018. These turnout rates are typical across many years’ elections. Elder voters account for a disproportionate share of the electorate, relative to their 2019 population share. The other groups’ population shares are more commensurate with their electorate shares.

Once again, the Dems are emphasizing increased turnout for young people and Hispanics, as well as non-Hispanic Black folks. If the Dems’ efforts succeed in improving these groups’ turnout it could likely benefit their candidates. But in past elections such efforts have largely come up short with regard to younger persons. Interestingly, California has a proposition on its ballot that would further expand youth voting privilege by allowing 17-year olds to vote in primaries and special elections if they will be 18 by the time of the next general election. OMG, say it ain’t so.

The Dems are also hoping to get Bernie Sanders’ and Elizabeth Warrens’ progressive believers to vote for Joe. Both Bernie and Elizabeth are thankfully far more engaged in promoting the Dems’ candidate than they were four years ago. The question remains whether Progs will really shed their puritanical mental frocks and actually cast a ballot for Biden, despite their believing he’s not “pure” enough. Fingers are crossed in hoping they are not all like Roger Williams, a strict Puritan leader, nearly 400 years ago.

The Dems’ challenges illustrate a long-running political dispute about election strategy: Is it better to persuade people who will likely support you to actually vote by increasing turnout or to win over swing voters and change the vote margin?

Both are important for achieving victory, but past elections indicate it is more valuable to win by changing the vote margin than by changing turnout. Why? Because successfully changing a persuadable voter to change her/his sides (change the vote margin) produces two votes: plus one for you, and minus one for your opponent. Getting an additional voter to cast a ballot through turnout is worth just one vote. Also, an election’s vote share/margin also tends to shift more than turnout from election to election. Thus, changing the margin ends up being more politically “efficient”, netting two votes versus one vote, but can entail more convincing efforts.

I’m trusting that despite #45’s relentless all tricks and no treats, the thoughts of #16’s Secretary of State William Seward (who bought Alaska for us at a pittance) remain true: “There was always just enough virtue in this republic to save it; sometimes none to spare, but still enough to meet the emergency.” In our current emergency we’ll find out soon if Sec. Seward was right, as I truly hope.

 



[1] For you national election geeks, Belgium has the highest voter turnout with 87.2% of the voting-age population actually casting votes in their latest national election.




 



Thursday, September 17, 2020

SHOULD I MOVE BACK TO PHILADELPHIA?

Venus favors the bold. ~ Ovid 

It seems to me that the fall election will be the day after tomorrow. The intensity of media’s circus about all things electoral is being ratcheted way up – with more than Barnum’s three (3) rings and a mere 46 days remaining before November 3.

A growing bask[1] of poll results are published daily. Incessant interviews with allegedly undecided voters pervade the media. Come on, how could any semi-cognizant person 18yrs or older remain unresolved about voting for either Biden or Trump? The number of “swing” or “battleground” states –where someone has decided the expected election results are “too close to call” – have multiplied this time around. Past elections have categorized three or four states as swingers, not now. Last week there were 12 to 15 states that have been labelled “swing/battleground” by various organizations.

Fifteen states, really? Absurdity lives on both sides of the screen. Either the polls’ always-suspect forecast accuracy is getting worse, or the cabal of pollsters and media have determined it’s decidedly inequitable that only a couple of states get so anointed. Each of the 15 swingers must deserve a participatory blue or red tinted ribbon.

According to one analyst, Pennsylvania will likely decide the presidential election among the swingers. Sorry Wisconsin, Minnesota, Ohio and Florida. Your time in the election spotlight’s glare has apparently dimmed. So, if the Keystone State is indeed the key state, should I move back there – I grew up in suburban Philadelphia – and vote to help Joe win? Is my additional vote worth more there than in the People’s Republic of Berkeley, where I’ve resided for decades?

To see if I can still actually legally cast a vote in Pennsylvania I visited the comprehensive www.vote2020-womentowomen.com/ website that Patrice and her friend Linda Saulsby recently launched. I learned I need to relocate in PA no later than October 2 and register by October 19. It would be a rather quick hop, skip and a long jump back to Liberty Bell-land. Recent polls of likely voters in PA show Biden leading #45 by 3% to 7%, indicating that more Biden voters will help.

Each and every vote counts of course, and in the last presidential election Sec. Clinton beat The Donald by a significant 30.0% margin in my home state, California. In Alameda County, where Berkeley dwells, her victory margin was an incredible 63.6%. She received 5.4 votes for every vote Trump got. These results illuminate California’s and my home county’s status as deeply midnight blue territory. The most recent polls of likely voters in CA show Biden leading from 29% to 30%.

On the other hand, #45 won Pennsylvania in 2016 by a miniscule but vital 0.7% margin even though the state has been Democratically-aligned for a long time. The Dems’ presidential candidates have won PA in 10 of the 17 elections since 1952. Before 2016, the Dems triumphed the last six straight presidential elections. But now politicos believe PA is getting redder. As Democrat cognoscente James Carville stated, “Between Pittsburgh and Philadelphia, Pennsylvania is just Alabama.”

I cast my first presidential vote in November 1968 for Hubert Humphrey when I lived in Montgomery County, one of Philadelphia’s four “collar counties” that surround it. In 2016, Montgomery County gave Sec. Clinton a 21.3% winning margin.

In order for Biden to win PA this time around, these four collar counties (and Pittsburgh’s Dem majority) must surmount #45’s strength throughout the far less urban rest of the state. That, unfortunately, did not happen in 2016. It most assuredly needs to happen this November 3.

In his disastrous town hall meeting held in Philadelphia this week, #45 talked about “herd mentality” – yet another of his ever-lengthening list of spoken misnomers – when he likely meant herd immunity. Actually, from this I believe he and his deceitful campaign has been exposed for using heard mentality to inure his base from the real world and instead accept his fearfully-spoken dark fantasies.

I haven’t booked a flight to PHL yet. I’m hoping Joe and Kamala will continue bolstering their fearlessly bold and clear advantages to the voting public. They should keep emphasizing their positivism, humanity, knowledge, credibility, common sense and perhaps most importantly, empathy for every US resident.

I also haven’t scheduled a journey to our closest planetary neighbor, Venus. I found the report that astrobiologists may have discovered phosphine (PH3) in Venus’ atmosphere emotionally-positive news. On Earth, phosphine can be produced either by microbes or chemists (including as a lethal by-product of hazardously-operated meth labs).

That’s right, possibly some beyond-strange microbial lifeform could be floating next-door in the Venetian atmosphere. Wow; welcome to the planetary neighborhood. Unfortunately there’s no beaches to travel to (it’s a toasty 900°F on the surface), but what an escape from the onslaught of a covid-flu twindemic, wildfires, the on-going viral recession and vicious politics.

To Venus and beyond…

 



[1] A bask is the collective noun that describes a group of crocodiles, a treacherous reptilian carnivore. 



Wednesday, September 2, 2020

ROLL OVER BILL PHILLIPS

You gotta hear it again today

The way to crush the bourgeoisie is to grind them between the millstones of inflation and taxation. ~ Vladimir Lenin 

The certified nation-builder, Vladimir Lenin, mentions above that inflation can be the bane of many people, even the bourgeoisie. He’s right. Milton Friedman, a certified Nobel-laureate economist, but not at all a fan of Lenin, stated that inflation is taxation without legislation. He’s right, too. They agreed about nothing political, but do agree about the harsh effects of inflation that reduce the purchasing power of money.

Inflation is a general rise in a nation’s prices. Not just the increasing price of fruit loops, Airbnb rentals or window panes, but all prices in a country. Economists cite woeful, recent examples of unchecked hyperinflation such as Venezuela’s 27,364% inflation in 2018, when prices doubled about every two weeks and Zimbabwe’s 66,000+% inflation in 2009. The “winner” in my national hyperinflation hall of fame is Hungary’s unfathomable 1946 general price increase of 9.63 x 1026 percent (prices doubled in less than every one and a half days). Post-war periods and inflation often coincide. Even here in the good ol’ USofA. Cliometricians estimate that in 1779 the US had an inflation rate of 192%, mostly caused by the Revolutionary War’s substantial costs.

Have you experienced noticeable national inflation? Not unless you’re over 35 years old with virtuous long-term memory. The last time the US core Personal Consumption Expenditure price index (PCE), that our Federal Reserve Bank uses to measure official price changes, reached 5% annual inflation was the third quarter of 1983. The PCE has only been over 2% – the Fed’s target inflation rate – in merely two (2) of the most recent 40 quarters (10 years). Long gone are those economically-stormy, early 1975 days when inflation rose to 10.1%.

Thus, with perceptible inflation thankfully being in a long-term coma it’s hardly surprising that last week Federal Reserve chair Jerome Powell and his colleagues altered the Fed’s policy priorities. Going forward, the Fed will re-emphasize its goal of minimizing unemployment rather than its second goal, controlling macro prices (e.g., inflation). The Fed stated that low unemployment would no longer be a sufficient reason to tighten monetary policy, in an attempt to head off expected inflationary trends. In a remarkably truthful statement, the Fed’s wizard vice-chair, Richard Clarida, stepped in front of the curtain to state that the Fed’s macroeconomic models that have predicted inflation would always rise significantly when maximum employment was reached were wrong.

Apparently, Senate leader Mitch McConnell didn’t get this Fed memo, as he’s staunchly refusing to re-vitalize expansionary fiscal expenditures – such as the former $600 unemployment supplement – to ease the lives of too many people, and reduce unemployment. Mitch dismisses the facts that unemployment is now 10.2% and folks are suffering.

For a long time, both the Fed’s goals were nominally given equal policy priority. This dual prioritization was essentially founded on the Phillips Curve. In case you’ve forgotten this slight theme presented in Econ 101, here’s a recap.

The Phillips Curve is named after Professor William Phillips, my favorite New Zealand economist. He gained my fancy in part because he’s the only economist I know of who was a crocodile-hunter in his youth. After fighting in Southern Asia during WWII, he headed for London and enrolled in the London School of Economics (LSE). At the LSE he became captivated by the then quite radical, newish view of macroeconomics created by John M. Keynes and became an academic economist.

In 1958 Professor Phillips published his seminal paper that described an inverse/indirect relationship between a nation's wage-inflation rate and the unemployment rate using early-20th century United Kingdom data. When either unemployment or inflation is low, the other is high, as illustrated below.

The Phillips Curve 











Source: Forex

When similar patterns of wage-inflation and unemployment were observed in other nations at the time, the Phillips Curve became accepted by both academics and policy-makers. If an economy was growing with lower unemployment (higher employment), the Phillips Curve posited that higher wages/inflation will happen. It displayed the short-run macroeconomic trade-off between a strong economy (lower unemployment) and higher inflation.

This relationship has not held in more recent times despite considerable efforts to defend the Philips Curve and its shape. Some macroeconomists have differentiated short-term versus long-term Phillips Curves, others have added inflationary expectations to no real avail. I’ve believed the Phillips Curve has been a chimera for quite some time. But the Congress and the Fed, as well as other nations’ legislatures and central banks, still use the explicit Phillips Curve’s inflation-unemployment relationship for justifying policy.

When inflation appears set to rise, the Fed has typically tightened the money supply (by increasing interest rates), generating a little more unemployment. When inflation is poised to fall, the Fed has done the opposite. The result is that unemployment edges up before inflation can, and goes down before inflation falls. Monetary policy (and to a much lesser extent fiscal policy) is changed so that inflation will not.

But inflation has appeared to be less sensitive to differing employment levels, as mentioned above. Inflationary pressures have been in a coma. This past February (a lifetime ago) when the macroeconomy was quite strong with very low 3.5% unemployment, the PCE inflation rate was a remarkably quiet 2.1%.

The Philips Curve has apparently flattened over the past decade, so that a given change in unemployment, due to variations in monetary and/or fiscal policy, has had a smaller effect on wages/inflation than previously. This change is the basis for the Fed’s recent prioritization of fighting unemployment with much less concern about eventual inflation.

Oh my, Professor Phillips, your curve has broken down and metamorphosed over time to be far flatter, in spite of some macroeconomists’ best efforts to explain this change and do something about it. The Fed is going to focus now principally on promoting employment, downplaying price-stability.

That’s perfect timing because we’ve been in a significant recession for at least five (5) months. The Fed’s Board of Governors now will “appreciate the benefits of a strong labor market, particularly for many in low- and moderate-income communities.” After this Spring, when the Fed began its sizeable efforts to reduce the pandemic’s recession, will inflation awaken from its long, Ambien-induced torpor? A pro pos of the well-known Niels Bohr quote, predicting inflation is very difficult, especially about the future. But it appears that most economists and market analysts, despite voluminous and contrary opinions, do not think noteworthy inflation is anywhere near imminent.

I think the recent flatness of the Phillips Curve has contributed to the rise and spread of progressively-liberal economists’ Modern Monetary Theory (MMT). A simplified tenant of MMT argues that countries which issue their own currencies, like the US does, can never “run out of money.” The federal government is not financially constrained in its ability to spend. MMT claims that the government can afford to buy anything that is for sale in its currency with minimal concerns of resultant inflation.

Ironically, when Dems come into full federal power on January 20, 2021 with enough of them subscribing to the flatter Phillips Curve and MMT, they could embrace the Repubs own de facto fiscal policy that has exploded the federal budget deficit with their specific, pet fiscal initiatives like giant tax cuts for corporations and for the bluest of the rich as well as ever-increasing defense expenditures, with no discernible rise in inflation.

By brandishing the Phillips Curve’s modern flatness, adopting MMT and pointing a fiscal mirror at #45’s and the Repubs’ massive deficit spending, progressive Dems could justify, with enough backbone, their own expensive, pet fiscal initiatives. Ones like the Green New Deal, government-guaranteed $15/hr jobs and Medicare for All. It could be the Dems’ way of stating, if you Repubs can do and have done it, we can too for far broader benefit.

In my mind, it all started with one clever, crocodile-hunting Kiwi economist.

 



 

Sunday, August 23, 2020

TIGHT QUARTERS

You must be the change you wish to see in the world. ~ Mahatma Gandhi 

You might have missed this, but on February 3, when a virus wasn’t an all too central part of our attention, the US Mint in Philadelphia issued its newest US quarter-dollar coin. This coin, shown below, displays our very first President, George Washington, who has continuously appeared on our quarters since 1932 – no term limits for quarters apparently. Our newest quarter celebrates American Samoa on the relief (back side), which features a mother fruit bat and her pup hanging upside down. Aren’t you numismatists now excited? 

   The newest coin is part of the US Mint's America the Beautiful Quarters Program. According to the Mint, “the image evokes the remarkable care and energy that fruit bat mothers put into their offspring. The design is intended to promote awareness to the species’ threatened status due to habitat loss and commercial hunting. The National Park of American Samoa is the only park in the United States that is home to the Samoan fruit bat."

So start swimming across the Pacific to Samoa – it’s only 4,805 miles from here – and lend assistance to these threatened fruit bats. The Philadelphia Mint is no penny ante or mere nickel and dime operation; it usually produces 13.5 billion coins every year that represent 1.2% of the nation’s money supply. This spring, there were close to $48 billion worth of coins circulating. But the Mint’s production of coin has decreased due to measures put in place to protect its employees from the virus.

There are not enough quarters, or as I’ll refer to them here, Georges. Just like TP and paper towels, the coronavirus is now blamed for a shortage of quarters. This shortage isn’t the result of more young people playing coin games like deadbox or tinks, like I used to in grade school.

Only 70-90nm in size, roughly one-hundredth as large as a human red blood cell, the coronavirus has been blamed for aggravating virtually every shortage, inequity and malady.[1] The covid-19 pandemic is everywhere. The word pandemic, first used in the mid-1600s when the Great Plagues of Europe were killing 20% to 50% of the population, comes from the Greek pan demos (all people). In a viral variant of Parkinson’s Law that cannot be masked; the coronavirus has inevitably expanded so as to fill the time available for everyone’s fears and opinions. And, of course, it’s far from over.

The only comparable, politically mesmerizing event I remember is the 1973-74 Oil Embargo when suddenly, and belatedly, we realized that oil was a vital ingredient for a vast spread of economic activity and whose supply was no longer guaranteed. This embargo incented some economists to develop a BTU theory of value which measured a good’s worth based on how many BTUs (of then very scarce oil) were required to produce it. Thankfully, a covid theory of value hasn’t evolved, yet. Has it?

Nevertheless, as everyone knows from personal experience, the coronavirus has extensively changed our behavior. These behavioral changes include how much we’ve been spending and how we’ve been paying for purchased items. Paying for stuff requires some sort of money, which for economists like me leads to talking about “types” of money and the money supply. The US money supply is managed by the Federal Reserve Bank (the Fed), our nation’s central bank.

Simply put, the larger our money supply the more spending happens. The more spending that occurs the higher our GDP. The Fed has demonstratively supported keeping the US economy relatively afloat during the covid crisis. Over the past year, the Fed has increased the money supply by nearly $1.5 trillion dollars, an amazing 38.5% growth rate. That is a whole bunch of dollars, and Georges. It’s also a prime example of big-time expansionary monetary (money supply) policy. In July, retail sales slightly increased (1.2%) for the third straight month, after significantly dropping earlier in the year.

There are several types of money, including cash (like Georges and dollars), credit and debit cards, checks, and zeros and ones (digital money). With the exception of cash, most monetary transactions end up as zeros and ones in your (or someone else’s) account.

There’s more money circulating, courtesy of the Fed, but Georges and other change are in tight supply. Because of the apparent shortage, the Fed has rationed coin supplies to banks across the country. That’s not necessarily a large macro issue because coins aren’t used in many high-value non-digital purchases. Federal Reserve research indicates coins and cash are used only in about 12% of purchases costing $100 or more. Such transactions thus don’t provide much change, which is not the same as what Mr. Gandhi was referring to at the beginning of this blog post.

But coins and other cash are used for 49% of payments below $10. That’s why laundromat operators are wondering where George is. Laundromats are quarter kings because their washers and dryers require them to operate, as you probably remember.

There are about 29,500 coin-laundries in the US, generating nearly $5 billion in annual gross revenue. It costs the typical laundromat customer about 8 quarters to wash her/his clothes and about the same to dry them. Some laundromats charge less (6 quarters), some more (16 quarters).

Most laundromats provide on-site change machines for their customers so they can use the washers and dryers. The stores’ owners/operators thus need a steady, substantial supply of Georges. That’s becoming more challenging. Charles, a laundromat owner, drives to six banks in his city every morning in search of Georges. The banks now each limit him to no more than $120 worth (480 quarters). Most recently, he’s been running low on Georges, which is bad for his business: no quarters, no washing or drying.

He and other small business-people believe the coronavirus has somehow blocked coins from circulating in the economy. Many non-essential businesses remain closed, perhaps with their unemptied register tills on the premises. People are making fewer shopping trips, and depending on the store type, buying less per visit. That is happening, but it’s not just the supply of Georges and other cash that may have shrunk because of the virus, it’s also their velocity.

Money velocity is an economic term that measures the rate (speed) at which money is exchanged for goods or services in the economy. It’s the rapidity at which people and firms spend their money. Unlike driving on the Interstate, money velocity has no regulated speed limit, it depends on the size of nation’s macroeconomic output (GDP), relative to the size of the money supply.

US money velocity has lessened over time. From the beginning of 2020 through June 30, money velocity dropped 23%, a big reduction. Velocity is at its lowest in 60 years. Lower money velocity means each dollar (and quarter) is not being used as often to buy things. This lower demand for purchasing items produces lower GDP. The US real (inflation-adjusted) GDP dropped 9.5% from the first to the second quarter of 2020.

Despite the Fed’s successful efforts to increase the overall money supply, money velocity has significantly dropped as has the supply of coins. Lower velocity mitigates some of the effects of the money supply's increase. Georges and other cash are being used less to purchase of goods and services.

Where’s George when we need him?

 



[1] The media has taken to multiplying the pandemics we’re facing, so hardly anything is left out of its realm: witness media sightings of the fashion pandemic, the housing pandemic, the wildfire pandemic, the Great Barrier Reef pandemic, the schools' laptop pandemic… 



Friday, August 7, 2020

COBOL AND COVID

My pitching philosophy is simple: keep the ball away from the bat. ~ Satchel Paige 

Infrastructure. You’ve heard this word so many times it no longer perks up your or anyone’s attention. When I think of infrastructure, I imagine roadways, airports and bridges. Merriam-Webster’s rather non-descript definition of infrastructure is: “the system of public works of a country, state or region.”

Infrastructure isn’t exciting or stimulating. That’s basically why there are far more politicians who love to promise they’re going to amp up infrastructure spending than actually put dollars to work improving it. Infrastructure’s considerable value stems from enabling many appreciated economic and social activities to happen. Like Little Red Riding Hood driving her EV on her town’s freshly-paved streets to visit gramma’s house (and avoid the big bad wolf), or using her town’s public water system to clean her fine, red hoodie in her water-efficient washer.

Last fall, the Congressional Budget Office estimated that combined federal, state and local spending in 2017 on infrastructure was $441 billion, roughly 2.3% of GDP. This estimate represents the lowest level in more than 60 years. Infrastructure spending peaked at about 3% in the late 1950s, when the Interstate highway system was being constructed.

The Interstate System is perhaps the best-known Federal infrastructure program. Its 47,000 miles cost about $129 billion, making it the nation’s largest-ever public works program. Every state has an interstate highway. The first segment of an Interstate highway was begun in 1956 in the Show-Me state of Missouri. The state with the most Interstate miles is Texas (3,501.2mi.); the one with least is Delaware (40.6mi.).[1]  

Roadways are an example of traditional infrastructure that’s easily seen and used by the public. The Coronavirus pandemic has exposed a series of failings in our public infrastructure that is more hidden but nonetheless has created calamities for lots of us. I’ll talk here about two types of fading public works.

First, Covid testing. The CDC’s initial requirement of only using state and local government testing laboratories to diagnose Covid-19 in individuals produced tragic consequences. Despite #45’s completely spurious claims, neither the CDC or these public labs have accomplished their clearly-understood objective of providing sufficient, reliable and timely testing.

Six months into the coronavirus’ incessant attack, the US has yet to adequately deliver enough dependable testing in a timely fashion. In August the US ranks 12th of the 91 nations listed in terms of total per capita coronavirus testing – 173.8 tests/1000 people. Luxembourg is first with a testing rate that’s four (4)-times higher than the US. The media regularly reports people having to wait so long for their results that the findings are medically meaningless. Like all too many others, one San Francisco person finally received his test results 16 days after taking it.

Another veiled, unseen form of vital public infrastructure that’s stumbled in its efforts to surmount substantial viral challenges is the government’s digital infrastructure, its computer systems and personnel. These computer systems enable the panoply of federal/state/local government program payments to be received by intended recipients – like Social Security, SNAP/food stamps, Medicaid/Medicare, tax refunds and, of recent note, unemployment insurance benefits (UI). The pandemic has strained federal, state and local governments’ assistance programs beyond anything imaginable over the last 80 years.

Our public digital infrastructure has floundered because many public agencies haven’t prioritized or been allowed to update their systems for decades. They’re typically legacy mainframe systems, with a very capital “L”.

As of July 25, over 54.1 million American workers, representing more than one in three workers in our labor force, have filed for UI. That’s more than 37 times higher than normally expected, pre-virus. The national unemployment rate peaked in April at 14.7%, the highest since the Great Depression. Our real (inflation-adjusted) GDP fell 9.5% during the last quarter. Over 100,000 small businesses have likely closed for good. Well-known retail businesses have also declared bankruptcy like Lord & Taylor, Sur La Table, Brooks Brothers, Hertz, JCPenney and Chuck E. Cheese.

In response to this medical, economic, social and wholly-human catastrophe the Congress passed its first Covid pandemic support legislation on March 27, the $2.2 trillion CARES Act. Among countries, the US is not known for its generosity to the unemployed. However, the CARES Act provided significant fiscal support for workers, firms and many others harmed by the coronavirus, including a $600 per week supplement to the unemployed. This multi-faceted support totaled 13.2% of the nation’s GDP, placing the US program third largest in the OECD, a group of advanced nations, behind Japan and Canada. In this age of “do-nothing” government, the CARES Act embodies an impressive, timely accomplishment.

But nothing lasts forever including this Act, by design. Alas, the Dems and Repubs have wasted time pointing fingers of blame rather than agreeing what the scope and form of a successor Covid support program should be.

The House Dems easily passed their $3 trillion follow-on package, called the HEROS Act, on May 15. Meanwhile the Senate Repubs are tardily drafting their follow-on package, entitled the HEALS Act, that could provide $1 trillion of benefits. [Don’t you just love how every piece of legislation needs an acronymically-suitable title.] The winner of the HEROS v. HEALS political prizefight has yet to be determined.

No matter how the new legislation finally gets squeezed through the Congress’ political meatgrinder, it will likely be very challenging to implement by state agencies that administer unemployment benefits. Why? Because the vast majority of state unemployment insurance agencies use ancient computer systems.

The age of state benefits agencies’ computer systems ranged between 22 and 42 years old, according to a survey that was performed over 10 years ago. These mostly mainframe hardware systems are digital dinosaurs that use obsolete programming languages like COBOL. The first COBOL program ran in August 1960, that’s 60 years ago folks, on an RCA 501 mainframe computer.[2] Because of their nearly-geologic age, state unemployment insurance agencies’ computers are costly to run, fragile, inflexible and error-prone. Their operation requires continued attention by knowledgeable personnel. It’s no surprise that very few computer jockeys know (or want to know) anything about such archaic systems – most have retired long ago. Hiring knowledgeable staff for such computer systems is a nightmare. Doc Brown’s DeLorean might be a useful staffing tool.

During the 2007-09 recession, when these agencies were last obligated to produce rapidly rising numbers of benefits payments, their legacy computer systems regularly failed. No real system changes were needed, only larger than usual volumes. Many shut down for days after the systems attempted to handle the elevated claim levels.

This Spring, the CARES Act implementation required substantial amounts of angst-inducing time and effort by state UI systems’ operators to redesign their systems to add the uniform $600/week federally-funded supplementary payment to qualified recipients. The federal Treasury Department had similar, time-consuming technical difficulties in providing millions of citizens with their $1,200 payment checks. Many of these challenges centered on the agencies’ obdurate computer systems.

Notwithstanding their possible merit, if the provisions of the Senate’s proposed HEALS Act go into effect, such challenges would multiply. States would need to provide supplementary UI money that would equal 70% of an employee’s lost weekly wages (but not exceed $500/week), when added to existing state benefits. This represents a major change from the CARES Act $600/week supplementary payment.

As such, this HEALS Act stipulation would give many states’ UI systems yet another coronary. To make this seemingly straightforward 70% calculation would require rapid introduction of new revisions to legacy software together with likely linkages to additional databases. What could go wrong when changing lumbering, inflexible, archaic hardware/software systems? How long would it take? Don’t ask and don’t hold your breath.

Perhaps these recognized obstacles are the reason the Senate’s HEALS Act surprisingly provides $2 billion to help states “upgrade” their ancient UI systems. Surprising because the vast majority of Repubs are loath to provide any funding that assists state and local governments.

I would be amazed if the final House-Senate compromise legislation includes any payments that depend on such semi-sophisticated computations. The regrettable state of public digital infrastructure will limit Congressional negotiators to arguing about levels of dollars per week, not percentages of lost wages. It’s another case of public law and action being effectively constrained by woebegone infrastructure.

In this confrontation between COBOL and Covid, keeping it simple – following Occam’s razor – is the only expedient maxim. 

August 11, 2020 postscript. Another COBOL & Covid interaction. The CA state health director abruptly resigned on August 10 amid CA’s rising case/death rate and a big snafu with Covid-related health data. Why the problems? From the story: The governor on Monday vowed to quickly overhaul what he described as the state’s outdated information technology systems, which he blamed for not just the testing data snafu, but also for a staggering backlog of unemployment claims .

 



[1] Until the District of Columbia convinces Congress it should become a state, it’s just a district with 12.3mi. of Interstate. You shouldn’t hold your breath for DC’s latest statehood effort to be successful.

[2] At that time, my father served as the senior RCA executive in charge of its computer systems business. 



Saturday, July 11, 2020

DAMNATIONS

When the well is dry, we learn the worth of water. ~ Ben Franklin, Poor Richard's Almanac  1733

Water is perhaps the most essential ingredient for life on Earth. Nevertheless, we humans have never learned how to share it. Although the Earth is literally bathed in water, only 0.5% of the planet’s water is accessible fresh water; hence the challenges of apportioning it.
     Shared riparian water-rights are rarely non-disputed, especially when it comes to dams. This website lists over 700 individual water-related disputes of various sorts around the world, including military ones, since the end of WWII. The website’s beginning dispute happened around 3000 BCE.
Beavers have been building dams for millions of years, humans for a much shorter, but substantial period. A dam, whether built by beavers or humans, restricts and retains the flow of riparian water and forms a reservoir behind it. The stored water in dams’ reservoirs can be used to contain floods, as well as provide water for irrigation, navigability, human consumption and power production. The world’s first hydroelectric power plant began generating electricity in Wisconsin in 1882.
One of the earliest human-built dams is the Sadd el-Kafara (the Dam of the Infidels). It was built by ancient Egyptians for flood control on Wadi al-Garawi – south of Cairo – around 2950-2750 BCE. Alas, it was destroyed by a flood before it could be completed. Settled-agriculture, which was already well established in and around Mesopotamia by then, augmented humanity’s needs for water management and storage.
We haven’t let that initial tragedy at Sadd el-Kafara blunt our building as there are now about 57,000 large dams worldwide. Virtually every country is a damnation. These dams’ reservoirs cover more than 154,000 square miles – roughly the area of California. Speaking of which, there are over 1,400 named dams and 1,300 named reservoirs just in the Golden State. The largest dam in California, the Oroville Dam, is the 8th biggest dam in the world (by volume of fill/structure) and the tallest in the US (770ft.).
An African dam now being built has captured the media’s attention, the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam (GERD). Ethiopia started construction nine years ago of its GERD on the Blue Nile, the main tributary of the Nile river. About 85% of the Nile’s water is sourced in Ethiopia. The dam’s site is situated just 9 miles east of the Ethiopia-Sudan border.
When operating with a full reservoir, its 6.45-gigawatt electricity capacity means this dam will be the largest hydroelectric power plant in Africa, as well as the eight largest in the world (by capacity), right behind the US Grand Coulee Dam. It will more than double Ethiopia’s electricity output and make a significant contribution to Ethiopia’s further development. The majority of Ethiopians do not have any access to electricity.
The GERD represents case #797 (and counting) of fluid, multi-society water-usage antagonism. The dam is now producing some power, although it’s only about 70% complete. Nevertheless the GERD has already generated a great deal of rancor between Ethiopia and its two neighboring, Nile River basin nations; Sudan and its far more powerful downstream neighbor, Egypt. Thus, the GERD’s three damnations are Ethiopia, Sudan and Egypt. Each has an unsurprisingly distinct position regarding the dam.
Ethiopia ($858 GDP/capita[1]) wants to fill the reservoir as fast as practical so the nation can start earning a return on its nearly $5 billion investment. Its government hopes the GERD will raise Ethiopia out of poverty.
Egypt ($3,202 GDP/capita) argues the dam represents an indisputable national threat because it relies on the Nile for 90% of its heavily-subsidized fresh water. It fears the GERDs restrictions on downstream water, especially during droughts, will reduce its water availability and waterflow into its Aswan High Dam, 900 miles downstream. Egypt wants Ethiopia to fill the GERDs reservoir gradually and release water so the river’s flow isn’t much altered. Because the Nile and Egypt have been closely-intertwined throughout its multi-millennia history, Egyptians believe the Nile and its water is their birthright.
Sudan ($442 GDP/capita), although it supports the GERD and will receive some of its inexpensive electricity, it is concerned that any of the GERD’s un-coordinated water releases could overwhelm its own Roseires Dam, 140 miles downstream. Sudan demands predictable GERD water flows so it can grow more food for its starving, vulnerable population.
According to reports, these three damnations have reached agreement for 90% of a deal; that remaining 10% will likely take labored conciliations on each nation’s part. Water is sometimes thicker than political blood. Meanwhile Ethiopia is soon scheduled to start filling the GERD’s reservoir.
     Much closer to home, one long-standing domestic and international water dispute involves Mexico and the seven (7) US states that comprise the heavily-dammed Colorado River basin. California’s “water wars” have been on-going for over a century. A commission was established in 1884 between Mexico and the US to oversee the flow of the river’s water from the United States through Mexico into the Gulf of California. Sixty (60) years later, the Commission negotiated a US-Mexico multi-river treaty for the two nations’ water usage.
     California, Arizona, Nevada, New Mexico, Colorado, Utah and Wyoming – the Colorado River basin’s US states – continue to negotiate among themselves because Southern California takes more water than it is entitled to under the Law of the River. One enduring, intra-California water dispute involves Southern California again making waves by demanding an ever-larger portion of Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta water. The Southies want water shipped to Los Angeles via the 700-mile California Aqueduct. Predictably, Northern Californians are unwilling to accede to such ultimatums.
And it started with the Dam of the Infidels five thousand years ago. Onward…





[1] These nominal GDP per capita numbers are for 2019, according to the World Bank. 




Wednesday, July 1, 2020

MONUMENTAL PROBLEMS

“Our monuments are representations of myth, not fact.” ~ Ken Burns 

 An early 20th-century European thinker wrote after WWI that “there is nothing as invisible as a monument.” During the past month, monuments have once again become not only visible, but lightning rods of attention.
Although our advancing, covid-based circumstances have brought out the humanity in many people, the media isn’t all that interested in such positivism. Far more prominent are the clashes and divergences.
     One of the latest of such clashes is what I liken to Monumental Problems. Especially those that are related in some folks’ view to events connected to the recent, unlawful and criminal deaths of Black people. The latest victims include George Floyd, Emmet Till, Michael Brown, Breonna Taylor, Rayshaard Brooks and Ahmaud Arbery who themselves have become the now-justly-memorialized foundation of the Black Lives Matter movement.
The bronze monuments of George Washington, Robert E. Lee, Robert Gould Shaw, Teddy Roosevelt and other leaders from the past have been sundered, toppled, defaced or removed by spirited crowds. Removing Mr. Lee and all of his Confederate cronies is completely warranted.
San Francisco protestors took down a statue of our 18th president, Ulysses S. Grant, whose military successes ended the Confederacy. But because he was given a slave whom he later freed before the Civil War, his sinful calumny was complete according to the activists. I don’t believe statues of President Grant should be destroyed. His personal fault is outweighed by his noteworthy and substantial public efforts to preserve the US and halt its disunion.
The protestors’ searing focus rests on specific facets of the bronzed leaders’ broad careers. The protestors, using their severe standards, want to demonstrably rectify these leaders’ past injustices. Meaning deposing these leaders’ no longer invisible statues. Thirteen (13) of our first 18 presidents were slave-holders. In retrospect, it’s a thoroughly ghastly record. The 1860 US Census documented that 12.6% of our national population – over 3.9 million people – were slaves. Should we now topple the Washington Monument because George (and Martha) had over 300 slaves at Mt. Vernon, or demolish the Jefferson Memorial because he had about 200 slaves?
The challenge is how we reconcile our distinctly-different, present-day moral judgments together with a recognition that our past describes an utterly differing nation. Can we the public resolve the protestors’ solitary focus on a single attribute of these leaders’ lives as a rationale for these statues’ destruction? Honestly, I find it difficult. Does that make me a racist?
Monument denouement is by no means new. On July 9, 1776 the Declaration of Independence was read aloud for the first time in Manhattan, NY to George Washington and his soldiers. Afterwards, his American patriots quickly went to a near-by park and toppled the statue of King George III of England, the colonies’ then-ruler. Soon thereafter the king’s lead sculpture was melted down to make musket ball-bullets for the muzzle-loading, flintlock rifles of Gen. Washington’s army. King George was thus converted into 42,088 bullets. This transmutation of the king’s statue into revolutionary ammunition has a certain exquisite irony. It was a-propos both of the patriots’ spirit of 1776, as well as the logistical realities of our war for Independence. The picture below shows a lead musket ball mold that my long-ago family ancestors used during the Revolutionary War and afterwards.


Monumental Problems are not limited to the present day nor to the US. Next year will commemorate the 150th anniversary of the toppling of Napoleon Bonaparte during the Paris Commune revolt. Not of Bonaparte’s rule or the man himself (he died 199 years ago), but of his memorial statue atop the Vendôme Column in Paris.
Similarly, three decades ago freedom-fighters in Ukraine and Hungary knocked down statues of their historic tyrants, Lenin and Stalin. A statue of Winston Churchill, who helped save the free world from massive Nazi brutality, was vandalized in London last weekend because of racist statements he once uttered.
Alas, there is no such thing as a pure past, or present. Like everyone, leaders are filled with human frailty, bias and defects. The past provides no untainted innocents. Utopian-minded protestors, understandably angered by present-day and past atrocities, demand retribution from bronzed likenesses of leaders who, despite other achievements, have strayed from the protestors’ thin, imagined lines of currently-defined purity.
I believe this movement offers yet another signal of refocused generational shifting. In many Millennials’ and Gen Z’s view, us Boomers’ facile dismissals of such egregious wrongs merits utter distain. How dare there be a statue of slave-holder President Grant prominently displayed in San Francisco’s Golden Gate Park.
We should recognize that inter-generational criticism is a timeless truism, present throughout the past and present. Perhaps the only certainty about the future is that some aspects of today’s life will be disparaged by generations to come.
Young people inevitably are accused of having insufficient respect for their elders, enjoying outrageous music and practicing increasingly strange rituals. Conversely, today’s younger folks disparage the ignorant beliefs and behaviors of their parents and earlier generations.
Really? What beliefs and behaviors of ours could possibly be belittled? Here’s a partial list: criminalizing homosexuality, not stopping or at the very least mitigating climate change, eating meat, prohibiting women and minorities from voting and not sufficiently combatting racial, economic and social inequities. Young people and others believe slavery, although legislatively outlawed in 1865 by the Constitution’s 13th Amendment, has continued to exist in other, not so sub-rosa forms ever since. Its continued presence now needs to be halted.
Hence, the inevitable Monumental Problems.