Wednesday, February 3, 2021

COVID VACCINE DISTRIBUTION IS A MESS

 Everyone has a plan until I punch them in the face. ~ Andrew Cuomo     

It is no surprise that the distribution of Covid vaccines has proven challenging. Getting precious vaccine into 330 million Americans’ arms was never going to be a slam dunk, given the fractionalized nature of our healthcare system.

We should not downplay or forget the astonishing success of the development of these vaccines. The vaccines were created with technological brilliance at near light-speed –with $18.5 billion of federal government support. But the vaccines’ distribution is another matter.

Supply shortages of the Covid vaccines have been expected and present since Day 0 of their distribution. This scarcity have been mostly sidestepped by politicians. They rarely couch their Covid pronouncements with clarity about how long increases in vaccine supply may happen, except to make generic (and optimistic) statements about the future.

With my medium-priority status as an ancient diabetic in mid-December I estimated there would be 124 miles of people ahead of me in Alameda County’s line to get the vaccine. That translated into my being in back of 2,954 miles of folks in California’s line. While proverbially waiting in either line, I needed to remember at least to bring a camp chair and water.

Forecasts of vaccine availability have always been colossally optimistic. Last Fall, Operation Warp Speed stated there would be 300 million (M) vaccine doses available in the US by the end of 2020. By the mid-December, the CDC said it expected between 30-45M doses by yearend. In fact, only 1,008,025 doses were administered by last Christmas. Should we believe updated dosage forecasts that are stated by “experts”? I’d advise against it.

At this point, vaccine supply isn’t expected to increase at all before two months from now for the already-approved vaccines. Why? Because additional production capacity is currently unavailable.

If all the now-expected supply were used, the US could average over 2M shots per day, but state and local vaccination centers have failed to manage and use the current flow of vaccine, let alone more. So why are governors adding even more “prioritized” people to the vaccine-eligible lines with no additional supply until April?

Some relief will come once the Johnson & Johnson single-dose vaccine gets FDA emergency use approval. If expeditiously approved, the J&J vaccine might start to be available in early March according to the experts. J&J has agreed to deliver 100 million doses to the US by the end of June, assuming smooth sailing. Are you holding your breath?

Covid vaccine distribution has been a calamity in California and elsewhere. Fundamentally, the vaccines’ delivery system is founded on a conflict between the inclusive logic of having ever-more people become safer by getting fully inoculated – something politicians and everyone else wants to happen the day before yesterday – and the selective logic arising from shortages of vaccines because at any point in time there’s a fixed, inflexible supply that is far less than the public’s demand.

To reduce the shortage, vaccines have been rationed, requiring some people to be non-prioritized and thus having to wait. No public official ever uses the term rationing to describe the situation because of its fraught connotations. But that’s what is behind the CDC’s and each state’s tiers and sub-tiers. Unsurprisingly, the alluring artform for some of securing “unfair priority” to jump ahead in the line is itself reaching epidemic proportions.

As of February 1, California has vaccinated 7.2% of its residents with at least one dose, 1.5% with two doses, and utilized just 61% of all doses delivered. California ranks 38th highest of all the states for doses utilized. Each of these percentages is below the mediocre US averages. Nevertheless, thank goodness vaccination rates are slowly rising.

State politicians have established “vaccine delivery systems” that involve many interdependent moving parts among multiple agencies/institutions grating together, in which every piece needs to work rapidly, competently and seamlessly for success to occur. It hasn’t.

This week Dr. Anthony Fauci, now President Biden’s chief medical advisor, acknowledged this very problem, “You cannot give a definite answer [about when the Covid vaccine system will return us to “normal”] when you have so many moving parts.”

I’m reminded about such challenges in keeping our multi-faceted Covid vaccination systems working by this image of Charlie Chaplin in his renowned 1936 Modern Times movie. So many gears, so many parts grinding on each other that have to be kept working flawlessly together. No wonder he and we are exhausted.

Charlie Chaplin enjoying Modern Times.

California’s vaccine distribution system has been changing rapidly, which adds yet another fateful, often confusing influence on getting this essential task done timely and effectively. If it’s Wednesday, do I keep unsuccessfully calling an 800 number, or do I use the newly-introduced but error 408-laden website? The systems’ shortcomings have resulted in every relevant party pointing fingers, at others.

Gov. Newsom’s approach seems to pay only slight attention to the vaccines’ omnipresent shortages that everyone is facing despite California’s utilizing only 61% of delivered vaccines. His approach that emphasizes inclusive vaccinations has increased the demand for the vaccine. Not the supply.

Gov. Newsom announced January 13 that the state was “significantly increasing our efforts to get these vaccines administered, get them out of freezers and get them into people’s arms” by increasing the number of people eligible to receive shots to everyone 65 and over. Except sufficient vaccines aren’t available for an additional 6 ½ M elder Californians.

And the governor knows every person demanding a shot is a voter, be they a healthcare worker, elder, school teacher, parent, diabetic, firefighter, meat processing plant worker, lettuce picker, or grocery worker – virtually all of whom consider themselves “essential” in some manner.

Thus, the governor’s system has all too often worsened the situation by increasing the number of “prioritized” people who qualify for getting the vaccines, without a concomitant boost in supply, over which he has no control.

Individual states cannot directly contract with vaccine suppliers, only the federal government is allowed to. Thus, exhortations by governors like New York’s Andrew Cuomo about ordering their own vaccines have, at best, only fleeting PR value, but no legal or practical consequence.

Pfizer’s and Moderna’s production facilities have been running at full-tilt 100% capacity. As mentioned before, the intricate vaccine production process cannot change that rapidly, even if governors like Mr. Newsom somehow expect it to with the flick of a few words.

Thus, the lines get ever-longer; the public’s expectations are rarely met and people understandably get more upset and frustrated. Hence, the emergence of a misbegotten campaign to recall Newsom, promoted by the ever-endangered species, California Republicana.

Perhaps this political action is part of why Gov. Newsom last week again changed his vaccine distribution system. This time more fundamentally. Until last week, the governor’s delivery system revolved around the state’s Public Health Departments (PHDs) who had responsibility for allocating the vaccines across the State, county by county.

He shocked California’s vaccine delivery system by removing the PHDs. Critics said the PHD-based system was a piecemeal patchwork of confusion. The authority of the PHDs should have been sidelined long ago in favor of larger-scale healthcare providers who are far more experienced dealing with customers, and already have the systems to do so.

The governor’s new vaccine management-distribution system will be run by Blue Shield of California, with assistance from Kaiser Permanente, two of the largest healthcare providers who together serve more than 10M people in the state.

The PHDs have been challenged and stretched by their vaccine responsibility even before they officially started Covid vaccination management in mid-December. For years PHDs have been under-budgeted, understaffed and now they’ve became overwhelmed, which has led to their ineffectiveness. Their distribution efforts have been faulted for inflexibility, spotty data collection and a lack of statewide coordination among the 61 local health jurisdictions with regard to eligibility requirements.

One person familiar with California’s PHD-based system stated, “In short, there is no clear and easy way to tell people when it was their turn and where to go when it was.” Another knowledgeable observer said the bar for Blue Shield’s and Kaiser’s success is pretty low; “The whole thing has been managed so disastrously.”

My personal example: on January 14 I completed the online Alameda County Health Care Services’ Resident Vaccine Notification Form and submitted it – apparently to neverland. Since then, I have never received any notifications, even from Tinker Bell, about my status. On my own, I was vaccinated at Kaiser on January 19 via a phone call to Kaiser that included a 2.5 hour wait to get an appointment. Let’s hope my second dose isn’t delayed.

New York state has just made changes in its vaccine management system, similar to California for similar reasons. New York ranks 24th highest of all the states for doses utilized, at 65.7%.

After New York’s vaccine rollout became problematic and fewer available doses were actually being administered, Gov. Cuomo declined to adopt plans previously developed by the State Department of Health and local health departments. Recently he became more displeased with local public authorities’ and public hospitals’ poor performance, calling the PHDs’ operations excessively rigid. The magnitude of the pandemic had swamped New York’s public health planning efforts.

Finally, the governor said he punched the PHDs’ plans in the face, using a cheekbone-close adaptation of the famous Mike Tyson quote[1]. Late last week Gov. Cuomo announced that private hospitals now will be “hubs” for vaccine dispersal throughout the state, not PHDs.

Meanwhile back in Washington, President Biden is changing lots about #45s plebeian Covid plans. He has ordered FEMA personnel and active-duty soldiers to become directly involved with vaccine distribution. They will operate large, federally-supported vaccine centers in several states including Arizona, Nevada, Texas and Washington.

Additionally, the president’s Department of Homeland Security recommends that undocumented immigrants should be vaccinated, together perhaps with incarcerated people that others insist should be inoculated ASAP. If large numbers of such folks received dosages before “ordinary people,” it isn’t hard to imagine how badly the public might react. Such are the judgements #46 and other authorities now face.

So, here’s an FYI message to Charlie Chaplin (see above). In order to improve our Covid vaccination system, the president is adding additional large gears to the nation’s already hugely complex vaccine machinery. I’m sure you understand. Perhaps hope springs eternal with further intricacy. Let’s see how it all works, keeping every finger crossed, with uniformed and non-uniformed federal personnel now swiftly meshing with the other thousands who’ve been engaged in this herculean task for far longer. Onward towards herd immunity.



[1] Mike Tyson said “Everybody has a plan until they get punched in the mouth,” in response to a reporter's question about whether he was worried about Evander Holyfield's fight plan before their 1996 championship fight. It turns out Mike got punched and lost the fight. 




Thursday, January 28, 2021

THE HIGHER AND LOWER COMMONS

We will never be defined by tragedy, but instead by how we respond to it. ~ Kevin Brady 

A brief preface. Spring came two-months early this year for me – on January 20 – when Joe Biden was inaugurated as President and Kamala Harris as our Vice President. I am beyond delighted. Although we Americans still face significant challenges – the Covid pandemic and the recession, to name just two – my optimista feelings are far stronger and encouraging about getting through the next few whiles. I’ve sorely missed having these feelings for all too long, four years too long.

**   **   **

Common land has been an ancient and principal ingredient for humans’ progress. It’s land owned collectively by multiple people, or by one person, but which others have rights to use. Such rights have included pasture and pannage. Pasture rights allowed yeomen to let their livestock – cattle, sheep, horses and other animals – graze on the common land. Pannage is a common-land right that permitted crofters to turn out their pigs to eat nuts that had fallen on the ground from Oak, Beech and other trees in autumn. Yum.

Millennia ago, virtually all human pastoral groups held common land; millions of acres of open-field, common land existed for centuries. An example, below, is Buchans Field in Scotland, near South Lamarkshire, that was farmed as common land for nearly a millennium from the Middle Ages until the late 16th century. There’s much less common land now. 

Buchans Field, an area of Scottish common land .

One of the earliest and remaining examples of common land in North America is the Boston Common, dating from 1634, and now a center-city public park.[1] It’s the oldest city park in the US. In the 1630s this common was used by many people as a pasture for their cows. Alas, as families put more and more cows to feed on the common, while contentedly chewing their cuds, it began suffering from overgrazing.

In 1646 the Puritan elders ordered a limitation, that the common could have no more than 70 cattle/cows at any time to stop its ruin. It’s not clear if the elders’ limitation ameliorated this first American tragedy of the commons. It took another 200 years for this common’s authorities to formally ban cows.

What is clear, the Boston Common has not been the last American tragedy of the commons. The notion of the common has expanded greatly since 1968, when Garrett Harden wrote his ground-breaking article, “The Tragedy of the Commons.” In Harden’s view the actions of individuals using a common resource for their own, specific gain, without regard for others, will ultimately and tragically despoil and deplete these resources.

The modern characterization of the common or “common resources” includes not only land, but any jointly-held, open-access resource, be it land, rivers, oceans, the atmosphere or beyond. I describe now the status of two examples of commons, one new, heretofore uncommon and very high, the other lower and much more well-trodden.

The Higher Common.  Let’s get very high and talk about our space common. Yes, there is one. There are two portions of this higher common, so far. First, and farther away, is the moon.

The 1967 UN Outer Space Treaty that 132 nations have signed states that no government can claim the moon; it is wholly a common resource. The 1979 UN Moon Agreement strengthens this in saying lunar resources are the "common heritage of mankind" and must be shared.

When Neil Armstrong became the first human to step onto our moon on July 20, 1969. He and Buzz Aldrin called it a day after walking around in the lunar dust for three hours. My brother and I happened to be in London that day. We went to a local pub to celebrate Apollo 11’s pioneering success and were toasted by many equally-happy Brits who bought us as many pints as we wanted. That was a most uncommon day.

The second portion of space common is our planet’s atmospheric common, which is far more populated with human pursuits including much twirling debris. The first human-built, artificial satellite that entered our space common circling the Earth was USSRs Sputnik 1. It initiated the US-USSR Space Race.

Sputnik was launched into low-Earth orbit on October 4, 1957. The small (23 in. diameter) sphere with trailing antennae orbited for three weeks before its batteries died and then burned up in the atmosphere two months later. Going forward 63 years there are now over 2,218 operational satellites revolving in Earth’s space commons. Twelve nations and one regional organization (the European Space Agency) have launched orbiting satellites. The US has launched 859 satellites, the most of any nation.

There are also more than one million pieces of space junk also circling mother Earth. The bulk of orbital waste are small objects like paint flecks, metal parts and solidified liquids ejected from spacecraft. Also, the US Space Surveillance Network is continuously tracking more than 20,000 larger objects, like dead satellites and abandoned launch vehicle stages. The higher common doesn’t suffer from too many cows, it’s littered with mega junk.

Several manned and unmanned spacecraft have been damaged or wrecked by space debris. So, before you book your sub-orbital flight on Virgin Galactic from its Spaceport America facility near Truth or Consequences, New Mexico (here’s hoping it will all be truth, and no nasty consequences), you may want to check exactly how your pilot will avoid the ever-growing mess of low-earth orbital scrap. Virgin Galactic says they have 600 paying customers (a suspiciously round number), including Justin Bieber and Leonard de Caprio, ready for their $250,000 rides. Happy trails, guys.

A vital question is how to remove orbiting space junk, to reduce this higher common’s growing tragedy. Technically, it’s hugely challenging because of the technological hurdles associated with relevant orbital mechanics. Several possible means of dissipating the debris are being discussed. Very early, initial tests are planned, not any of which is ready for prime-time space garbage collecting. Crucially, none of the participants in the orbital marketplace is ready to answer the very expensive, key question, “who’s going to pay and how?” Until that happens, space junk will keep proliferating.

The Lower Common.  Back to Earth. The lower common doesn’t require a telescope or a rocket ship to see. Just take a gander at some terrestrial fresh water, perhaps the most precious resource that sustains our lives, next to the atmosphere. Fresh water is a finite, common resource needed by every living organism on a daily basis. For a very long time, even in the mostly-arid Western US, we have taken its availability for granted. That time is ending.

A recent example is the 2011 through 2014 severe drought in California, the driest in the state’s history. This was the latest one. There have been many other droughts that have affected western states on an all too regular basis, which we do our best not to think much about.

This devastating drought was principally caused by climatic conditions (as always), and magnified by misguided government policies governing the water market. I characterize it as a liquid tragedy of the common caused in large part by pricing water too low for too long for too many users.

The market for fresh water in the western US (and elsewhere) is highly regulated by federal, state and local public agencies. In large part, the tragedy is based on regulated prices of water that have never reflected the actual costs and value of providing and using it.

Substantial public subsidies, at the deep end of the subsidy pool especially for agricultural (ag) irrigators, have kept water prices preferentially very low. Thus, there has long been over-consumption and inefficient usage of this common resource. Six years ago, over 210,000 California water customers were not even metered for their usage, including in Sacramento and South Lake Tahoe. These customers pay a flat rate no matter how much water they use.

Agricultural irrigation users have benefited the most from inexpensive water prices. They consume about 80% of California’s fresh water all by themselves, and for decades have paid downright benthic, rock-bottom lowest prices of any users.

The uppermost prices that large-scale California irrigation customers pay are only about 20% of what residential water customers shell out. Even though urban water’s prices that you and I pay are typically faint (e.g., 1.4¢ /gal.), they’re much, much higher than irrigators’ prices. A 5:1 price ratio between urban and ag users is common; with ratios as high as 10:1 in some areas.

Such large price differences between irrigators and residential customers have enticed new entrants into water markets. Specifically, well-funded private investment firms are purchasing relatively inexpensive age-old water-rights from farmers or water districts so they can eventually then sell to urban districts for a profit. These firms are making money the old-fashion way in a new context; in this case as water arbitragers, by inexpensively buying a truly liquid asset and selling it higher to other customers.

Why would farmers sell their property’s water rights? The investment firms are offering them attractive prices. Farmers have traditionally seen their land as their 401(k). But the parched Western US with its ever-increasing urbanization requires more and more water for residents. This is especially true for urban areas surrounded by low-rainfall desert, like Las Vegas and Phoenix.

For ag irrigators throughout the seven-state Colorado River basin and in the Central Valley, their retirement funds now are far more likely to be their riparian water rights rather than their acreage per se. Their water-rights are becoming worth much more to private investors than their land.

This shift of water rights from the common to absentee investors is changing who controls one of the most valuable resources in the US, publicly-owned water. If this continues, I would characterize it as a re-Cadillacing of western water resources, apropos of Marc Reisner’s classic book, The Cadillac Desert, in which he castigated preposterous federal and state water development policies. Where the lower common ends is anyone’s guess; not even the Puritans’ successors know.

 



[1] Indigenous, native American peoples used common land to graze their animals and sow crops for centuries, long before 1634. 




Friday, January 8, 2021

BUILDING BRIDGES TO NORMALCY

Bridges are the most invisible form of public architecture. ~ Bruce Jackson 

Hurray for Raphael Warnock and Jon Ossoff in their victories last Tuesday. Their unexpected, hard-fought double triumphs mean the Dems’ will soon control of all three branches of the federal government – the House, the Senate and the White House.

The last time the Dems controlled the federal government was from 2009-2011, during the first two years of President Obama’s initial term. Their control was solid but not durable; it only lasted until January 2011. The Repubs swept control of the House with a massive net gain of 63 seats from the Dems in the Nov. 2010 mid-term elections.

As President, Joe Biden will need to rapidly build many bridges to navigate the rough road back to his and our ever-evolving vision of normalcy. That will be no mean feat necessitating focus and mastery. Such bridges have nothing to do with structural engineering, everything to do with civil engineering, with us civilians.

    Bixby Creek Bridge, Big Sur, CA

Undoubtedly, Chuck Schumer and Nancy Pelosi have been closely working with soon-to-be President Joe Biden in how to most effectively use their power. Their unified control must be purposeful and directed so it might continue beyond 2022’s mid-term elections.

The Dems’ multi-faceted coalition creates challenges for President Biden and his stalwarts, even after winning both peachy Senate run-off contests. Early prognostication about the Dems’ dual victories cite massive Dem voter turnout as a principal factor. Truly impressive with giant thanks to folks like Stacey Abrams.

These victories now provide a 50-50 split between Dem and Repub senators that can and will be broken by Vice-President Kamala Harris’ tie-breaker vote as President of the Senate. She’ll likely be spending a fair amount of time at her Senate Dias.

This volatile 50-50 Senate equanimity has happened just three times in US history. Once in 1881, next in 1958 and most recently in 2001, during the George W. Bush administration.

Nineteen years ago, the Dems’ Senate leaders ultimately convinced Repub Senator James Jeffords (VT) to switch parties and become an Independent within the Dem caucus. The Dems’ enticed Sen. Jeffords by promising him the chairmanship of the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee. Sen. Jeffords’ switch gave the Dems slender control of the Senate, 51-49. Praise be for a Machiavellian delight.

Despite the Dems’ incipient control, Prog legislatively-based nirvanic hopes will need to be reined in as a thoroughly unlikely prospect. Why? Because there will not be 50 Democratic senators who would vote for programs like Bernie Sanders’ essential ones (below). Except perhaps infrastructure expenditures, which although perennially popular are both notoriously difficult to enact and take a long time to effectuate (more than 24 months). Also, it’s likely that Repubs would not make up for any inevitable dearth of Dem votes on bills that can’t satisfy every single Dem.

Strongly liberal Progressives should glide down out of campaigning’s stratosphere where everything is verbally possible (e.g., passing Bernie’s seven Essential Programs) and return to the grounded nitty-gritty political reality of having a slim one-vote margin of control in the Senate.

Joe Biden’s Key Campaign Programs

Bernie Sanders’ Essential Programs

Economic Stimulus (ver. 3)

Medicare for All

Healthcare Reform

Social Security Expansion

Climate/Environment Improvement

12-week Parental and Medical Leave

K-12 Education

$15/hr. Guaranteed Federal Jobs

Higher Education

New Infrastructure

Housing

Free College

 

Student Debt Cancellation

Est’d Cost: $7.7 trillion

Est’d Cost: $42.5 trillion

     In order to achieve any satisfactory accomplishments, President Biden must choose what program of his key ones he will commit to as tippy-top importance and become law of the land during his first 100 days. This sounds straightforward. The only impossible thing is how to make such a choice. For President Biden the choice is made that much more challenging because of sky-high expectations for his nascent administration.

Governing isn’t at all the same as campaigning. It’s always easier to create a comprehensively long to-do list as a platform; the above table is Exhibit A. That really is what campaigning thrives on. It’s far trickier and consequential to state what should be postponed or, oh my goodness, not acted upon when in office.

My bet is President Biden will first push hard for a third stimulus package including vaccinations, as numero uno. This stimulus, perhaps $2T, should wisely emphasize benefits for folks in real need, not those making $100k/yr.; and somehow keep the bridges to nowhere totally unbuilt. Maybe by limiting the bill to no more than 810 pages? What comes afterwards will involve a slugfest.

The new president’s now-narrower majority in the House (11 votes) and slimmest of majorities in the Senate (1 vote), will require considerable dexterity and discipline to get any legislation passed by Congress. The Dems Senate caucus cannot afford any of its members to stray, which has always been a trying task.

The 50-50 Senate balance will provide potential leverage to individual Dem senators to demand accommodation on particulars of an important Senate bill to ensure their vote. Give and take on any evolving piece of legislation is a given. How effective such demands might be will depend on the skills of Sen. Schumer and his likely Whip, Sen. Richard Durbin. Sen. Durbin’s life on The Hill will be worthy of many Xanax on an all too regular basis because getting to 51 is going to be an on-going challenge.

Another Dem possibility would be to pursue what they accomplished in 2001 when the Senate last enjoyed an unnatural 50-50 vote split. If they haven’t already, newly-Majority Leader Chuck Schumer and Sen. Durbin should focus on convincing at least one Repub Senator to emulate Sen. Jeffords’ switch to Independence.

Could political lightning strike again in the Senate? Perhaps, with phone calls and masked meetings with the Senate Majority leaders with Repub senators like Susan Collins, Lisa Murkowski or perhaps Mitt Romney. Such a switch might take advantage of the public’s outrage at Repubs for the Trumpian mobs’ insidious storming of the Capitol. Not being a Repub suddenly has much more potential value, especially when it comes with side benefits like a committee chairpersonship. Niccolò would be pleased. An additional vote or two would become a valued insurance policy for President Biden’s legislative hopes.

Nevertheless, with 51 votes the Dems can confirm Joe’s nominees for Cabinet positions, for federal judgeships and even for a seat on the Supreme Court should one unexpectedly become open.

The Dems now must also plan to use the legislative “reconciliation” budgetary mechanism to pass certain legislation. Reconciliation can only be applied to a bill if it’s related to revenue, spending or the national debt limit. Reconciliation allows the Senate to pass legislation with just 51 votes, because it’s not subject to filibuster rules that that require 60 votes for passage. That’s nine (9) more than they now have.

But reconciliation limits the number of bills that can be passed in each area and cannot be used to pass legislation unrelated to the three areas. Giving Dreamers a path to citizenship, or creating a public option within Medicare would not likely pass strict reconciliation criteria.

Alternatively, President Biden will certainly use his powers to make executive policy changes via the Executive Order (EO) procedure. In spite of his past criticism of #45s expansive use of them, he will also be signing his own EOs after Jan. 20th. Perhaps the Dreamers will realize citizenship through an executed EO, rather than a signed piece of legislation. Joe will be quite busy signing EOs, as well as initiating a Dept. of Justice investigation into how #45 should be charged with sedition. Just a thought.

Here’s deeply hoping President Biden’s Inauguration goes smoothly and the Capitol police will actually do their jobs this time. Goooo Joe!

 


 

Tuesday, December 29, 2020

BRAND NEW BEGINNINGS

 Beginnings are always messy. ~ John Galsworthy 

Greetings from the very near future – 1/21/21, only 21 days from now, and a world apart from yesterday.

Let me introduce myself. I’m Lefty Solomon, outside the newly-occupied White House, with Joseph R. Biden, Jr. (aka, Joe), in residence as our 46th president of the United States. Hooray! I’m loosely connected with several very liberal groups like Progressive Majority and People’s Action.

Actually, I came here yesterday, Jan. 20th, hoping to see #45 slunk southward to Palm Beach, but alas he must have cowardly used Harry Potter’s invisibility cloak and disappeared like a faux, manic King Lear. No surprise at all, really.

Because on last November 3rd we helped President Biden be able to move into 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue yesterday, strongly Liberal Progressives (SLPs) want Joe to initiate big changes without delay. For example, it’s way beyond time for all of us to adopt pandemic-induced social re-arrangements and priorities to assist the oppressed.

Starting with SLPs, we will all adopt universal immigrant status. The president should mandate everyone to do so as well. We’re all immigrants; at some point in the recent or deeper past, everyone’s ancestors came from another country (even Native-Americans way, way, way long ago who likely came from Asia). Such immigrant-status is positively crucial (see this story) for all to adopt so we can better see the world as filled with prejudice that must be slayed ASAP.

Likewise, “privileged” and “elite” status should become woebegone negatives. If your background or foreground involves being connected with at least “upper middle-class”, this status should be tentative. Upper middle class includes people whose earned income roughly exceeds $107,000. Remember, over 80% of Americans have called themselves “middle class.” Upper middle-class folks are about 15% of the population. Privileged, elite status should be quickly discharged.

Is it time to cancel all facets of inequality? We certainly think so. I present 33 “flavors” of inequality below that NYTimesters and other compatriots in the media have identified. This list is not meant to be all-inclusive. These facets of inequality include the old standbys of income and wealth disparity, as well as the environmental inequality of wild fires, inequities faced by being left-handed and discriminated farmers of color.

Strongly Liberal Progressives believe former privileged folks must mythologize their past far more adeptly. Therapy may help. They should perhaps consider themselves as children of hard-working, underpaid single-mothers joining with newly-adopted immigrants to rectify our inequality-filled world. Feels totally different, right? That’s a step in the right (or is it left) direction.

Time is of the essence, which raises two questions. Where are our not already-tainted “non-elites,” that we soooo desperately need to run the nation in a totally equitable fashion? And how will we get to true Total Equality without their and others’ help?

Regarding the second question, as you may recall in early January President Biden finally acceded to our SLPs’ demand to “equalize our society, now.” He tentatively agreed to create a new White House Office of Equity (WHOE) after we SLPs lodged our 54th major objection to his wishy-washy cabinet-level appointees that, in our eyes are undecided supporters of Total Equality and justice for all. I mean, how come Retired Gen. Lloyd Austin, President Biden’s pick for Secretary of Defense, has yet to announce he will defund the Military Police Corps?

Diana Moon Glampers, D.E. (Doctor of Equity), the soon-to-be appointed Handicapper General will be running the WHOE. She will rally her team to rapidly achieve Total Equity. And no, the new president has decided this “cabinet-level” position doesn’t need Sour Mitch’s or the Senate’s approval. Whew.

Finding funding for the WHOE is a slightly different matter, that we’re sure the president can surmount. After all, he will immediately cancel all contracts to build The Wall.

Dr. Glampers will properly handicap each and every above-average person in our great nation and “revert them to the mean.” And what a mean that will be; remember Joe the Plumber; remember Harrison Bergeron?

Clearly, Dr. Glampers will have her work cut out for her. She will be guiding us to secure a lot more equality in the US. Each of President Biden’s cabinet members will be strained by overwhelming public expectations to achieve significant accomplishments in record time. The Senate Repubs will joust against them. Not only that; he and his cabinet will be expected to interact with key Congressional Repubs, of all people, to follow the president’s strong direction for “meaningful dialog” with the enemy members across the aisle.

Less economic inequity means the US Gini Index, a measure of income inequality, will need to fall. The Gini Index has steadily increased since the 1970’s, indicating more inequality. Recently the US Gini Index was 41.5, securing a rank of 51st worst (highest) in the world. Dr. Glampers will want to push our Gini way back into its bottle towards a value of 25.0, which is equal to Ukraine’s, the most income-equal nation.

Who would have guessed Ukraine as being the nation with most-equally-distributed income of the 159 listed by IndexMundi? Not me and not likely Hunter. Nevertheless, let me be clear; even with this accolade, I’m not yet ready to move to Kiev.

Getting the US anywhere within a proverbial block of Ukraine’s Gini will be a fully-burdened political expedition on unknown, hazardous trails. Why? Because it will involve significant amounts of take-away by the government for many formally-privileged, elite people. It will certainly serve the interests of reducing inequality, but even I realize I’d better hold my political breath as long as possible.

Dr. Glampers also will be kept very busy creating new, needed policies beyond income and wealth redistribution, to staunch the spread of many other facets of inequality. I expect it will be a thoroughly fraught, but needed journey.

I hope your New Year’s was happy Diana because your days will now be super stressful and surrounded by many upset folks. We SLPs hope Themis, the Greek god of fairness, will be close at your side. Still, we stand right behind you in wishing you all the luck you can find; you’ll need it. Onward to utopian Total Equality. Here below is my list of inequalities, before my last comments.  

LIST OF INEQUALITIES

Here are 33 inequalities that have been identified in the media.  

#

Inequality Type

1

Income. Ye old faithful granddaddy measure of inequality. See Chartbook of Economic Inequality for actual #s over time for the US and other nations.

2

Wealth. The grandmommy of inequalities; where the real $$ are. See Chartbook

3

Left-Handed discrimination. Tell me about it.

4

High-school grads. We provide way more monetary support to college students; not enough for just high-school grads, over 70% of whom don’t go to college.

5

Inequitable environmentalism. Is environmentalism just for rich people? So it appears for environmental justice warriors.

6

Unequal joints. Smaller, independent marijuana growers can’t compete with “corporate” producers’ lower prices, squandering legal weed’s promise of a more equitable society.

7

Kids in poor communities often lack opportunities to play, unlike richer-families, e.g., sing, run free, and immerse themselves in imaginary worlds.

8

Environmental inequality of wild fires. Richer folks move back in, poorer folks can’t/don’t.

9

Health care. Even with the ACA, and the Repubs’ serious continuing efforts to eliminate it, 9.1% of people had no care (30M people).

10

Inequities connected with care and access for disabled people

11

Data-driven medicine “threatens to make a crushingly unequal system even more so.”

12

Economic growth. Dems’ legislation, never-to-see-daylight (until 1/21/21?), that would mandate the govt to calculate a new measure of quarterly economic GDP growth for each income decile in the US.

13

Inequality made worse by K-12 long summer vacations. But of courses.

14

Berkeley makes its libraries more “egalitarian,” and poorer, by eliminating overdue late fees that were judged inequitably paid by lower-income users.

15

Parents’ benefits at hi-tech and other firms; they get more benefits than non-parents.

16

Student debt crisis as ever-more young people attend post-HS education (college) they do it by borrowing. Total student loan debt is $1.59T. Median BA-holder debt= $32k (in 2019). Not strictly “inequality”, but hey.

17

Nannies/Domestic workers/Babysitters. These folks virtually always get compensated in cash. Thus, their income doesn’t include payment of any employment taxes, like FICA.

18

Criminal Justice. Blacks are arrested and jailed disproportionately more than other races. Such Inequities in criminal justice system for people of color have been noted since before the 18th century.

19

Employment. More young people, Blacks and Hispanics are unemployed than others. Higher unemployment for people with less than HS education and just a HS education than a college education, as always.

20

Executive employment. A disproportionately small share of S&P500 firms’ Board members (as well as other firms’) are women.

21

Generational inequities. More millennials are living with their parents that’s not always a happy place for anyone. And more Boomers are retiring and/or being subject to employers’ ageist policies.

22

Gender discrimination. Women have forever had unequal access to public buildings’ bathrooms, just eyeball the queues for the loo at any event. Build more of ‘em, and they will come. 

23

Dental inequality. We need better gum control. Medicaid does not offer dental care, which harms people’s health.

24

Cellphone gender gap. Women’s usage of cellphones in low- and middle-income nations lags behind that of men causing economic harm.

25

Property tax inequity. Hispanic and Black homeowners often face higher property tax assessment rates than White homeowners in the same tax jurisdiction.

26

Psychology of inequality. It had to be: it's human nature to compare ourselves to others. But that instinct can cause psychological stress. Where we think we stand on that ladder tells you a lot about a person's life and their life outcomes. Psychologists to the rescue? If only.

27

Farmers of color. Apparently young farmers and farmers of color have been “shut out” of govt ag aid programs.

28

Mobile inequality. Being able or unable to move from one location (say in a dense, urban, “super-star” city’s core) to another location is unequally available.

29

Vintage inequality. Income inequality has erased your chance to drink exalted wines.

30

Age discrimination. Age discrimination remains a significant and costly problem for workers, their families and our economy, says the EEOC.

31

Educational expenditures Community colleges and other non-“elite” colleges spend far less per student than other schools, exacerbating inequality.

32

Japanese skateboarders are nastily discriminated against. They dare not skate on the streets.

33

The covid-19 Pandemic’s unequal effects on people’s income, health, access to childcare and other aspects of modern life.

 

I admit, there’s a potential downside of identifying the many types of inequality that we SLPs and media stalwarts like the NYTimes continuingly add to. Honestly, I’m not at all sure that tallying ever-more specific examples of inequality will actually facilitate federal policies to be enacted that can remediate the consequences for victims.

Once there are dozens of inequality types to deal with, overall perspective maybe lost. Also, diminishing returns about the relative importance of each type will come into play as evermore types of inequality are found. Sort of like what’s now happening with allocating very scarce coronavirus vaccine to 330 million of us; where nearly everyone believes themselves to be essential.

When there are dozens of specific types of inequality, each with an identified group(s) of people who’ve suffered, the Biden administration may not be able to simply change income tax rates or inheritance taxes as a remedy. Even those policy changes will require huge amounts of political capital to enact. For us SLPs though, no matter how difficult it may be to increase income and inheritance taxes on privileged people, such changes should be very high on Diana’s and Joe’s list of things to do, no matter how many peachy victories we get next week on January 5.

Income and wealth inequality and their remedies have been kicked around by economists and politicians (mostly down the road) for a very long time. But still, it’s something that has a shred of clear corrective possibility at least theoretically. Now, with many newly-identified individual victim groups for many types of inequality, unique policy remedies will likely require specific remediations. Oh my. Such are the challenges in the future world of Strong Liberal Progressives.

 



Thursday, December 17, 2020

DON’T MESS WITH THE SOLSTICE

‘Twas the day before solstice and all through the town people wore masks…  

Happy Winter Solstice. In this leap-year the shortest day of the year – with the longest period of night - happens on Monday December 21,2020 (at 2:02a in Northern California). Thank goodness. Astronomically speaking, the winter solstice ensues in our Northern Hemisphere when the sun is at its lowest daily maximum elevation in the sky; when the sun is directly over the Tropic of Capricorn.

Amid the never-ending reminders of how many more tragic cases and deaths from the coronavirus occurred every yesterday, I’m ready to celebrate that each day will now gain a minute or two of sunshine. My celebration, and perhaps yours, is not new. Humanity has been solstice reveling for thousands of years.

Since before written human history, many late Neolithic and Bronze Age cultures observed the winter solstice as an important time of the year, punctuated by festivals, rituals and ceremonies. They marked the symbolic death and rebirth of the sun.

Physical examples include Newgrange (built in ~3200BCE) in Ireland and Stonehenge (built in ~3000BCE) in England – both constructed before the Pyramids of Giza – that are oriented for the winter solstice.

This astronomical event was often used to guide activities, such as the mating and slaughter of animals, the sowing of crops and the managing of winter food reserves. Starvation was common during the bare winter months. Scores of cultural practices are derived from the winter solstice time, eventually including Christmas. But Christmas festivities on December 25 were a long time coming.

Centuries before, Romans had been feasting during solstice-inspired Saturnalia. This festival honored Saturn, the god of plenty and liberation. Emperor Caligula extended Saturnalia’s party-filled celebrations to five days ending on December 23, as depicted below. Saturnalia included banquets, carnivals, merriment, gift-giving and no doubt debauchery. 

Happy Saturnalians

Christian authorities took over 300 years to decide that December 25 was their savior’s actual birthday. This date conveniently coincided with centuries-old Saturnalia party time. Christianity cleverly co-opted this ancient winter festival. It was easier to convert people into a growing, newish religion if the measures of daily life didn’t really change much. These early Christians partially succeeded even though they originally promoted the idea that the Messiah’s birthday was a serious time to be marked by reflection and abstinence. Their opposition to pagan customs like placing wreaths on front doors and carousing was an utter failure. Putting time-worn festivities back into the bottle proved to be a lost cause.

Nevertheless, over the centuries other fervent authorities have ignored the early Christians’ mistake of attempted eradication what they saw as citizens’ solstice-Christmas licentiousness. These authorities include the revolutionary anti-monarchist Oliver Cromwell, who as lord protector of England and leader of the English Parliament abolished Christmas in 1644. That’s right, he and his MPs agreed that if the people where not going to celebrate contemplatively, they shouldn’t celebrate at all. Partying was forbidden.

Cromwell’s subjects disagreed with riots ensuing across England. Revelry endured on the sly during the solstice and beyond. English Puritans and Calvinists continued to preserve their tightly-straightlaced, alcohol-free Christmases. Those must have been fun-filled times in the English Commonwealth republic.

But after the death of Cromwell (from malarial fever), Charles II, a mead-loving 30-year-old royal, became king in 1660. He forced the puritans to re-learn the lesson of history: Politicians who niggle with the holidays do so at their own peril. Mulled wine, ale and hard cider were joyfully served once again during the solstice. That, fortunately, continues.

However, some 360 years later, the coronavirus’ incessant spread has egged on authorities to consider strict injunctions on our social behavior during the solstice-holiday season to preserve public health. They certainly have justification; daily US coronavirus cases now exceed 240,000, an all-time high. But cancelling Christmas merriment remains an unpopular option.

Presidents, Prime Ministers, Governors and other heads of state have often, but not always, cut the public some slack regarding this year’s Covid-filled holiday restrictions to mitigate public backlash. Shown below are a few examples.

The US.  We’ve had no real president since the evening of November 3 (actually 1/20/17, but whatever). Nonetheless, the CDC’s current guidelines actively discourage holiday gatherings and travel. The guidelines state: The safest way to celebrate winter holidays is at home with the people who live with you. Travel and gatherings with family and friends who do not live with you can increase your chances of getting or spreading Covid-19 or the flu. Ta da, you’ve been forewarned once again.

California.  Governor Gavin Newsom has tightened restrictions, based on the percent of available capacity in local hospitals’ intensive care units (ICUs). Counties need at least 15% available ICU capacity to avoid stronger restrictions.

On December 17, the SF Bay Area’s ICU availability dropped to 12.6%, leading to an immediate, tighter stay-at-home order. This regional order prohibits private gatherings of any size, requires closure of all commercial operations except for critical infrastructure and selected retail operations and mandates 100% masking and physical distancing. Once triggered, these orders will remain in effect for 3 weeks (through January 7) at least. Santa and his widely-located elves will not be happy.

The United Kingdom.  Temporary “Christmas Bubbles” are allowed. A brief four-day respite around Christmas day will be allowed, has been introduced to allow people to celebrate in some fashion. There will be no travel restrictions and people will be able to mix indoors and stay overnight. The number of people who can mix is limited, nevertheless.

Italy.  The government has announced strict limits. Many Italian regions already have partial lockdowns. A 2½ week  ban on inter-regional travel beginning on December 21 has been announced. In addition, people will not be allowed to leave their homes on Christmas Day and New Year’s Day, with some exceptions. A curfew from 10p to 5a will also be in place. In a meager attempt to assuage his upset citizens, the Italian PM Giuseppe Conte has reassured children of all ages that Babbo Natale (Father Christmas) will definitely be visiting them on the 25th, as he is exempt from travel restrictions. Good luck with that Mr. Conte, and thanks for tiny favors.

France.  Travel restrictions are somewhat eased over Christmas. France has issued a nationwide curfew from 8p to 6a, which will be lifted on Christmas Eve, when the French celebrate, but not on New Year's Eve. Restaurants, bars, theatres and movies will stay closed. The flames of resentment are mounting and should be brighter by December 31.

Such restrictions are neither surprising nor inappropriate, given Covid’s onslaught. But still, siding with Saturnalians on Monday seems worthy as more light begins shining on us. Just don’t mess too much with our festivities, please. 

     Addendum. You may have heard that the Saturnalians have struck again and are providing a rare, additional celestial highlight for Monday’s Winter Solstice. Actually, it’s both the Saturnalians and the Jupiterians.

During this solstice Saturn and Jupiter will be visibly dancing together in our heavens the closest they have been in a very long time. It’s called their Grand Conjunction, the likes of which hasn’t been noticeable at night, nor this close, since Saint Francis of Assisi died. For those of you, like me, who haven’t kept up with Francis’ life, he passed 794 years ago in 1226. 

The media has dubbed this Grand Saturn-Jupiter Conjunction “the Christmas Star” to draw popular attention to it. Perhaps you remember singing the We Three Kings carol that mentions the Westward-leading still-proceeding three kings of Orient following the “star of wonder, star of night.” Yup, this time around it’s no longer the star of wonder, but a much less poetically-labelled Grand Conjunction.

If you’re in the San Francisco area on the solstice, go outside on Monday, look fairly close to the horizon after sunset, probably between 7p and 8p (Saturn and Jupiter set at about 8:27p) in Western sky (~249° W) to see this solstice’s unique “double-header”; the Grand Conjunction during the solstice itself. Onward through the stars…